By Zach Helder, Vice President, Agricultural Business Council of Kansas City
On November 3rd, voters dramatically overhauled the makeup of the U.S. Congress. Democrats are on track to win the national popular vote by nearly 14 percentage points, the biggest defeat of any party since the post-Watergate midterms of 1974. Further altering the bodies' composition is a record number of retirements.
Besides the changing of majorities, defeats, retirements, and leadership turnover have singularly affected the House and Senate agriculture committees. 7 of the 23 ag Senators are departing, including the former Ranking Member Amy Klobuchar. In the House, at least 14 members (over a quarter of the committee) are departing—including the would-be chair, Ranking Member Angie Craig (D-MN).
In the 120th Congress, agricultural leaders will encounter wholly different committees. Should a farm bill fail to pass before January 3rd, they will need to quickly forge new relationships and lines of communication—the committees will be drafting a farm bill, once again, from scratch.
The Leaders
The Senate
Chair (D) — Brown (D-OH) or Bennett (D-CO)
With Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) departing the Senate to serve as Governor, Senate Democrats will elect a new Chair of the Ag Committee. Formally, the Democrats' process is as follows:
The Senate Democratic Leader appoints the Steering & Outreach Committee
Steering nominates a candidate for each committee
The entire Senate Democratic Caucus votes yes-or-no by secret ballot
If a majority votes yes, the nominee will become chair
Alongside the Republican Conference's picks for Ranking Member, the Senate will formally approve the nominees by a unanimous consent agreement
Informally, committee seniority is the greatest influence in the process. Generally, the longest-serving member of a committee who both wants to be chair and does not chair other committees can expect the chairmanship.
Sen. Michael Bennett (D-CO) was considered the probable choice for chair of the Senate Ag Committee. However, his case is complicated by the election of Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH). The incoming Majority Leader is widely expected to grant Brown a waiver such that he is restored to the seniority consummate with his former service in the Senate (from 2007-2025). Such a waiver would make Brown the most senior Senate Ag Committee Democrat. With Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) set to chair Brown's former domain, the Banking Committee, Brown reportedly has his eye on the Ag chairmanship. Reporting may shed light on Democrats' planned resolution here, but the situation may otherwise be opaque until the Caucus completes its committee assignments and elections in late December or early January.
Ranking Member (R) — Boozman (R-AR)
Sen. John Boozman (R-AR) will be the only returning of the ag committee leaders, known colloquially as the "Four Corners."
The House
Chair (D) — Brown (D-OH) or Costa (D-CA)
With Rep. Angie Craig (D-MN) departing the House following her unsuccessful Senate primary campaign, Democrats will elect a new Chair of the House Ag Committee. The process resembles that of the Senate, with one important distinction: because the chairmanship is vacant, candidates may challenge the Steering Committee's nominee directly. Formally, the process is as follows:
The House Democratic Steering & Policy Committee, chaired by the party leader and composed of leadership, elected regional representatives, and appointed members, considers candidates for each chairmanship
Steering nominates one candidate for each committee
Because the Ag chairmanship is vacant, other members of the committee may nominate themselves or colleagues from the floor of the Democratic Caucus
The entire House Democratic Caucus votes by secret ballot, with a majority required to elect a chair
The House formally approves committee leadership through a resolution at the beginning of the new Congress
Unlike in the Senate, House Democrats have demonstrated a greater willingness to depart from seniority in selecting committee leaders. Indeed, Rep. Craig herself defeated more senior members to become Ranking Member in 2024.
Rep. Jim Costa (D-CA) is the senior candidate, having served in Congress since 2005 and representing California's agriculturally significant San Joaquin Valley. Costa unsuccessfully sought the position in 2024. However, Rep. Shontel Brown (D-OH), currently the committee's Vice Ranking Member, is widely considered the favorite (Yes, there may be twoBrowns from Ohio chairing the agriculture committees). Brown has reportedly secured support from Democratic leadership and members of the Congressional Black Caucus, and has spent much of the year building relationships with agricultural organizations. Rep. Don Davis (D-NC) has also expressed interest in entering the race.
The Democratic Caucus is scheduled to vote on contested committee chairmanships on December 9, at which point the contest should be resolved.
Ranking Member (R) — Thompson (R-PA) or Scott (R-GA)
Rep. Glenn "GT" Thompson (R-PA), the incumbent Chair, has reached the House Republican Conference's limit of three consecutive two-year terms as Chair or Ranking Member. Thompson has formally requested a waiver allowing him to continue leading Republicans on the committee. The process for selecting his successor, should that waiver be denied, is as follows:
The House Republican Steering Committee interviews interested candidates and selects a nominee
Steering is not required to follow committee seniority in making its selection
The full Republican Conference votes to approve the nominee, with a majority required
If the nominee is rejected, Steering must submit another candidate
The House formally approves the Republican committee assignments through a resolution
Rep. Austin Scott (R-GA), currently Vice Chair of the Agriculture Committee, is the leading alternative to Thompson. Scott has openly sought the position and would become Ranking Member if selected by Steering and approved by the Conference.
Thompson's waiver request is the central uncertainty. Although he has argued that continuity is important to completing the Farm Bill, reporting indicates considerable resistance within Republican Steering to extending committee leaders beyond their six-year limits. If the waiver is denied, Scott would appear to be the leading contender.
New Members
Senate Democrats
Adam Hamilton (D-KS), Josh Turek (D-IA), Scott Colom (D-MS), and Peggy Flanagan (D-MN) have each publicly stated their interest in serving on the Ag Committee—and it would be a surprise if any of them were denied the opportunity. Additionally, Turek speculated that James Talarico (D-TX) may be interested.
At the beginning of each Congress, the Majority and Minority will negotiate the proportions of membership on each committee. Assuming these negotiations could accommodate 14 Senators in the majority (and Brown is granted his waiver), the Senate Ag Democrats would be, in order of Seniority:
Sherrod Brown (OH) — Chair
Michael Bennet (CO)
Cory Booker (NJ)
Ben Ray Luján (NM)
Raphael Warnock (GA)
Peter Welch (VT)
John Fetterman (PA)
Adam Schiff (CA)
Elissa Slotkin (MI)
James Talarico (TX)
Peggy Flanagan (MN)
Josh Turek (IA)
Scott Colom (MS)
Adam Hamilton (KS)
Senate Republicans
The Senate Ag Committee will lose five of its twelve Republican members: Joni Ernst (R-IA), Mitch McConnell (R-KY), Tommy Tuberville (R-AL), Roger Marshall (R-KS), and Cindy Hyde-Smith (R-MS). The first three are departing the Senate, while Marshall and Hyde-Smith lost reelection. Consequently, only seven Republican members will return to the committee in the 120th Congress.
Senate Republicans select committee members through a Committee on Committees, with the Republican Leader exercising additional appointment authority. Committee seniority, members' preferences, and the agricultural significance of their states will influence the selection of new members. Because Democrats will control the Senate, Republicans will also lose seats on the committee, although the extent of that reduction remains subject to negotiations over committee ratios.
There are five newly elected Republican Senators, several of whom have particularly strong claims to an Ag Committee assignment:
Barry Moore (R-AL) served on the House Agriculture Committee during the 119th Congress.
Andy Barr (R-KY), who succeeds McConnell, has explicitly expressed interest in serving on the Senate Ag Committee and would bring fourteen years of House experience.
Harriet Hageman (R-WY) has made livestock and beef policy central to her legislative work.
Kurt Alme (R-MT) has emphasized agricultural exports, particularly beef, wheat, barley, and pulses, and would have a regional rationale for joining the committee.
Julia Letlow (R-LA) would also be a plausible candidate, particularly given Louisiana's rice, sugarcane, and other agricultural stakeholders, although she may prioritize other committee assignments.
Assuming the committee expands to 25 members, with 14 Democrats and 11 Republicans, four of the five newcomers could join. The projected Republican membership would be:
John Boozman (AR) — Ranking Member
John Hoeven (ND)
Chuck Grassley (IA)
John Thune (SD)
Deb Fischer (NE)
Jerry Moran (KS)
Jim Justice (WV)
Andy Barr (KY)
Barry Moore (AL)
Harriet Hageman (WY)
Kurt Alme (MT)
House Democrats
Democrats will experience remarkably little turnover among their incumbent House Ag Committee members. Only two of the current 24 Democrats are departing: Ranking Member Angie Craig (D-MN), who ran unsuccessfully for the Senate, and Shri Thanedar (D-MI), who lost his primary. The remaining 22 Democrats are expected to return, although some may seek different assignments now that their party controls the House.
The larger change will come from the incoming Democratic freshman class, which includes an unusually large number of members representing rural and agricultural districts. Several defeated Republicans who currently serve on the Agriculture Committee, creating strong arguments for their successors to seek those assignments.
At least three newly elected Democrats have publicly expressed interest in the Agriculture Committee:
Lindsay James (D-IA-02) has confirmed through a spokesperson that she intends to request Agriculture, although she is also interested in Energy and Commerce.
Sarah Trone Garriott (D-IA-03) has publicly stated that she will seek an Agriculture assignment. She defeated incumbent Ag Committee member Zach Nunn.
Rebecca Cooke (D-WI-03), who grew up on a dairy farm and defeated Ag Committee member Derrick Van Orden, has explicitly identified Agriculture as a preferred committee assignment.
Other likely candidates include:
Jamie Ager (D-NC-11), a fourth-generation farmer who operates Hickory Nut Gap Farm in western North Carolina and has emphasized agricultural policy throughout his campaign.
Christina Bohannan (D-IA-01), whose district includes substantial corn, soybean, livestock, and other agricultural production.
Randy Villegas (D-CA-22), who defeated incumbent Ag Committee member David Valadao in the agriculturally important San Joaquin Valley.
Bobby Pulido (D-TX-15), who defeated incumbent Ag Committee member Monica De La Cruz in South Texas.
Mike McGuire (D-CA-01), who will represent a predominantly rural Northern California district with substantial agricultural and forestry interests.
Jake Johnson (D-MN-01), who leads incumbent Ag Committee member Brad Finstad in an extremely close election. His prospective assignment remains contingent on the final election result.
Other Democrats who could reasonably seek an Agriculture assignment include Matt Little (D-MN-02), who succeeds Craig; Eileen Laubacher (D-CO-04), whose district includes Colorado's Eastern Plains; and Victoria Broderick (D-TN-04), who is in a closely contested race against incumbent committee member Scott DesJarlais.
Democrats are likely to have a House majority of approximately 260 seats. Assuming the Agriculture Committee retains its current 53-member size, a negotiated division of 31 Democrats and 22 Republicans would be consistent with the House's new partisan balance.
Under this scenario, the Democratic side would have nine seats available for newcomers. Assuming all 22 returning members retain their assignments, the projected committee would be:
Shontel Brown (OH) — Chair (projected)
Jim Costa (CA)
Jim McGovern (MA)
Alma Adams (NC)
Jahana Hayes (CT)
Sharice Davids (KS)
Andrea Salinas (OR)
Don Davis (NC)
Jill Tokuda (HI)
Nikki Budzinski (IL)
Eric Sorensen (IL)
Gabe Vasquez (NM)
Jonathan Jackson (IL)
Adam Gray (CA)
Kristen McDonald Rivet (MI)
Shomari Figures (AL)
Eugene Vindman (VA)
Josh Riley (NY)
John Mannion (NY)
April McClain Delaney (MD)
Chellie Pingree (ME)
Salud Carbajal (CA)
Lindsay James (IA)
Sarah Trone Garriott (IA)
Rebecca Cooke (WI)
Jamie Ager (NC)
Christina Bohannan (IA)
Randy Villegas (CA)
Bobby Pulido (TX)
Mike McGuire (CA)
Jake Johnson (MN) — pending final election result
The returning members are shown in approximately their existing committee order, while new members are listed as prospective additions. The chairmanship remains contested between Brown and Costa.
This scenario would bring three Iowa Democrats onto the committee, a substantial concentration for one state. Although all three have credible agricultural interests, Steering & Policy may prefer to distribute assignments across a broader range of states. Similarly, the eventual distribution of seats will be affected by incumbents seeking other committee assignments and freshmen competing for more prestigious committees.
The Agriculture Committee's comparatively accessible assignment process, combined with the large number of newly elected Democrats from agricultural districts, makes substantial freshman representation likely. The specific newcomers, however, will not be known until Steering & Policy and the Democratic Caucus complete their selections.
House Republicans
House Republicans face the greatest disruption of any of the four Agriculture Committee delegations. At least twelve of the current 29 Republicans will not return in January:
Don Bacon (NE) — Retiring
Scott DesJarlais (R-TN) — Defeated
Randy Feenstra (IA) — Unsuccessful gubernatorial campaign
Dusty Johnson (SD) — Unsuccessful gubernatorial campaign
Barry Moore (AL) — Elected to the Senate
Dan Newhouse (WA) — Retiring
John Rose (TN) — Unsuccessful gubernatorial campaign
Zach Nunn (IA) — Defeated
Monica De La Cruz (TX) — Defeated
Derrick Van Orden (WI) — Defeated
Rob Bresnahan (PA) — Defeated
David Valadao (CA) — Defeated
Additionally, Brad Finstad (R-MN) is closely trailing Democrat Jake Johnson and could increase the total number of departures to thirteen.
This unusually high turnover coincides with Republicans' loss of the House majority. Assuming a 31–22 Democratic-Republican committee ratio, Republicans will have only 22 seats available, compared with 29 in the current Congress.
Nevertheless, several of the incoming Republican members are particularly well positioned to fill vacancies:
Tom Sell (R-TX-19) is perhaps the most experienced agricultural policy specialist entering Congress. Sell previously served as Deputy Staff Director of the House Agriculture Committee, helped develop the 2002 Farm Bill, and subsequently founded the agricultural lobbying firm Combest, Sell & Associates with former Chairman Larry Combest. Sell has publicly expressed his intention to seek an Agriculture assignment.
Marty Jackley (R-SD-AL), South Dakota's Attorney General and a farm and ranch owner, has publicly stated his interest in serving on Agriculture. He succeeds former Ag Committee member Dusty Johnson and would restore South Dakota's representation on the panel.
Chris Stigall (R-MO-06) made securing a House Agriculture Committee seat a central campaign commitment, emphasizing that Missouri currently has no House members on the committee despite the significance of agriculture to the state's economy. The Missouri Soybean Association endorsed his candidacy and specifically cited his interest in the committee.
Amanda McKinney (R-WA-04) succeeds longtime Ag Committee member Dan Newhouse in one of the nation's most important specialty-crop districts. McKinney previously served as Vice Chair of the National Association of Counties' Rural and Agriculture Affairs Committee, providing an unusually strong background for a freshman appointment.
Chris McGowan (R-IA-04) succeeds former Ag Committee member Randy Feenstra in a heavily agricultural district encompassing much of western Iowa. McGowan has emphasized farm policy but he has also expressed interest in Armed Services.
Chuck Gray (R-WY-AL) succeeds Harriet Hageman and previously served on the Wyoming Legislature's Agriculture Committee. His experience and Wyoming's ranching interests make him another plausible candidate.
Former Representative Jerry Carl (R-AL-01), who is returning to Congress after a two-year absence, could also compete for an Agriculture seat. Carl previously served on the Agriculture Appropriations Subcommittee and has expressed interest in agricultural policy, although Appropriations could be a more attractive assignment.
Unlike the House Democrats, the Republican Conference will need to determine whether its remaining senior members wish to retain their Agriculture assignments. The prospective new Ranking Member, whether Thompson or Austin Scott, will play an important role in advocating for candidates, but formal selections are made through the Republican Steering Committee and approved by the Conference.
Assuming both Finstad and DesJarlais ultimately lose reelection, and the Republican delegation is reduced to 22 seats, the projected committee would be:
GT Thompson (PA) or Austin Scott (GA) — Ranking Member
Frank Lucas (OK)
Rick Crawford (AR)
David Rouzer (NC)
Trent Kelly (MS)
Mike Bost (IL)
Jim Baird (IN)
Tracey Mann (KS)
Mary Miller (IL)
Kat Cammack (FL)
Ronny Jackson (TX)
Tony Wied (WI)
Mark Messmer (IN)
Mark Harris (NC)
David Taylor (OH)
GT Thompson (PA) or Austin Scott (GA) — whichever is not Ranking Member
Tom Sell (TX)
Marty Jackley (SD)
Chris Stigall (MO)
Amanda McKinney (WA)
Chris McGowan (IA)
Chuck Gray (WY)